Fat type determines how quickly cookies spread during baking
Butter is a plastic fat: solid at room temperature with a moderate melting point (32-35C). As cookies bake, butter slowly melts, allowing the dough to flow and spread gradually, creating thin, crispy-edged cookies. Shortening has a higher melting point and stays solid longer, slowing spread and yielding thicker, chewier cookies. Oil remains liquid at all baking temperatures, spreading immediately and producing the thinnest, greasiest cookies.
The texture and flavor also vary. Butter delivers rich, savory notes. Shortening is flavorless and produces a crumbly texture. Oil keeps cookies softer longer and produces a denser crumb.
Emulsification and water content amplify the effect
Butter contains about 15-20% water, which generates steam during baking, promoting spread and lift. Shortening is pure fat with no water, so cookies rise less and spread less. Oil-based cookies minimize both effects. Emulsifiers (like lecithin in butter) also affect how the fat integrates with flour, altering crumb structure and final texture.